Transforming Health Care Through Evidence and Collaboration
Transforming Health Care Through Evidence and Collaboration

Overuse of Health Care by Commercially Insured Adults Varies Persistently by Region

Why This Study Is Important

Overuse of medical services occurs when the potential for harm outweighs the potential benefit from the service. Reducing overuse can help us to make wiser use of our limited health care resources and improve patient care quality. While most studies of overuse focus on specific individual procedures, one prior body of research has developed a multi-procedure index of systemic overuse in the Medicare population in order to analyze overuse as a broader phenomenon. This current study extends that work by adapting the Medicare index to the commercially insured adult population and by documenting regional and temporal patterns of systemic overuse for these individuals.

What This Study Found

  • The updated index revealed marked regional variation in the extent of systemic overuse among the commercially insured population.
  • Across the country, systemic overuse was lower in rural regions of states than in metropolitan areas. Numerous coastal metropolitan regions had high rates of systemic overuse, while much of the central and northwestern parts of the U.S. had relatively low rates of systemic overuse.
  • These geographic patterns were similar to patterns documented previously for the Medicare population.
  • Regional patterns of systemic overuse were highly persistent over time. More than half of the regions were in the same quintile of the overuse index in 2015 as they had been in 2011.
  • Just under 9 percent of regions — all of which are metropolitan areas — were persistently in the top quintile of overuse in all study time periods. Ten percent of regions had persistently low systemic overuse; one in five of these low-overuse regions was rural.

What These Findings Mean

The systemic overuse of health care services by patients with commercial insurance is an enduring regional problem. Rather than trying to curb overuse of specific individual services, addressing structural and system-wide factors that contribute to a “culture of overuse” is likely to have more impact for improving health care value. To that end, future research should investigate the regional characteristics associated with persistently high or low overuse as well as take a closer look at the small number of areas that exhibited meaningful reductions in systemic overuse. Additionally, replicating the overuse index for health systems or networks of clinicians within geographic areas may identify additional targets ripe for intervention.

More About This Study

This study used a large national database of health claims from 2010 to 2015 for working age individuals with employer-sponsored private heath insurance. Nineteen of the 20 procedures included in the original Medicare index could be evaluated with the available data, were relevant to the commercial population, and occurred with sufficient frequency and variation to be included in the updated index. Each claim was assigned to an MSA or statewide rural area based on the location of the patient’s residence. Indicators identifying every time a patient received any of the 19 overused services were used as the dependent variable in a multilevel regression model that included patient characteristics and procedural and regional fixed effects. The regional fixed effects captured each region’s systemic tendency for overuse across the 19 procedures. Standardizing these coefficients as a Z-score produced an index reflecting each region’s overuse relative to the average across all regions. Data from 2010 were used to adapt and validate the index, then regional index values were computed for each half-year interval from 2011 to 2015.

Full Citation

Oakes AH, Chang HY, and Segal JB. “Systemic Overuse of Health Care in a Commercially Insured US Population, 2010-2015.” BMC Health Services Research, 19:280, May 2, 2019.

For more information about this study, contact Dr. Jodi Segal at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
For more information about the NIHCM Foundation Investigator-Initiated Research Grant Program, contact Dr. Julie Schoenman at 202-296-4426.

Learn More

This Research Insights summarizes a new study on overuse of health care by privately insured adults, finding geographic patterns that persist over time.