Missed Opportunities to Prevent Cervical Cancer: Strategies to Increase HPV Vaccination
Current State of HPV Vaccination
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), vaccination rates for human papillomavirus (HPV) did not increase at all among adolescent girls from 2011 to 2012. Just one-third of girls aged 13-17 have been fully vaccinated against HPV despite the fact that the vaccine is included in adolescent vaccination recommendations and the fact that CDC safety monitoring data continue to indicate the vaccine is safe. In addition, research has shown that HPV vaccines currently available in the U.S. are nearly 100 percent effective in protecting against the viruses that cause 70 percent of cervical cancers. For each year that vaccination coverage levels fail to improve, an additional 4,400 women will develop cervical cancer.1
Following the release of the 2012 National Immunization Survey-Teen, CDC officials urged health care providers to increase the consistency and strength of their HPV recommendations. Research consistently shows that a provider’s recommendation is the single most persuasive factor for parents in deciding whether or not to vaccinate their child.2
Health plans are uniquely positioned to support providers in improving HPV vaccination rates. This fact sheet briefly reviews barriers to vaccination, the health and cost impact of HPV, and opportunities for health plans to support providers and educate members to increase HPV vaccination rates in the years ahead.
Why Aren't More Children Being Vaccinated?
- 19% “vaccine is not needed”
- 14% “doctor did not recommend the vaccine”
- 13% “concerns about the safety of the vaccine”
- 13% “didn’t know about the vaccine or the disease”
- 10% “daughter is not sexually active and therefore does not need the vaccine”
- Hesitance to discuss the vaccine if parents express mixed or negative opinions about the vaccine
- More likely to strongly recommend the vaccine to older adolescents than to 11- and 12-year-old patients
- Financial barriers related to the vaccine’s cost and reimbursement issues
Opportunities for Health Plans to Improve Vaccination Rates
Health plans can play a significant role in improving HPV vaccination rates by supporting in-network providers, educating their members and promoting the vaccine more broadly in their communities.
- Increasing the consistency and strength of HPV vaccine recommendations
- Recommending that HPV vaccine be offered at every health care encounter
- Developing incentives based on HPV vaccination measures
- Encouraging the reporting of HPV vaccinations to state or local immunization registries
- Urging that reminder notices be sent to parents of patients who are due to receive the HPV vaccine
Provider Education Materials
- CDC HPV Vaccination Resources for Healthcare Professionals:
- Provider fact sheet for talking to parents about the HPV vaccine:
- HPV Toolkit for providers
American Sexual Health Association: http://tinyurl.com/kdhlxlw
- Minnesota Quality Collaborative, Health Plan Performance Improvement Project: HPV Vaccination:
- Newsletters designed specifically for both adolescents and parents
- Attendance at health fairs and community events
- Fact sheets
- Social media like Twitter, YouTube or Facebook
- Segments on local television or radio stations
- Email and letters to parents of members eligible for the HPV vaccine
Journalism Grant Program
The 2020-2021 round of grant making for this program is now underway. Letters of Inquiry will be due by July 27, 2020.
Investigator-Initiated Research Grant Program
The 2020-2021 round of grant making for this program is now underway. The deadline to submit Letters of Inquiry has been extended to July 20, 2020.